Page 14 - JCBP-3-1
P. 14

Journal of Clinical and
            Basic Psychosomatics                                                    Somatic symptom disorder etiology



            examined,  rather  than  the longer-term tonic immobility-  in  response to  trauma  in humans.  Depending  on the
            related analgesia. 67-71  Sometimes important differences in   peritraumatic response, he said that either analgesia or pain
            the intensity and duration of SIA, varying in response to   is differentially regulated by either opioid or non-opioid
            escapability/inescapability, were not measured. For example,   mechanisms. In a fight/flight response to trauma, early rapid
            Pinto-Ribeiro et al. 69,70  reported long-term analgesia in rats   analgesia occurs through the prevention of SNS activation
            exposed to chronic inescapable stress but may have mistakenly   through epinephrine’s action (non-opioid) at the trigeminal
            interpreted the effect as due to hypercorticosteronism. What   dorsal horn and its deactivation of ACh in the PNS.
            is termed “elevated” or “high” glucocorticoid can vary   Alternately, in a freeze response, slower ongoing analgesia
            depending on the study. Pinto-Ribeiro  et al. exogenously   is maintained by ACh activation of the PNS, keeping the
            administered 40 mg of corticosterone to rats in the 2009   SNS “off” through endorphins opioid.  However, Janig
                                                                                               47
            study, presumably to match the levels her team noted in   was incorrect when he defined the initial attentive stillness
                70
            the plasma of rats subjected to chronic inescapable stress in   phase of peritraumatic perception, which occurs in both
            the 2004 study  (although those levels were not reported in   fight/flight and freeze responses, as the complete fight/flight
                       69
            the 2004 study). Forty milligrams would not be indicative   response. Instead, early SIA caused by attentive stillness is
            of hypercorticosteronism but instead indicates that low   characterized by cholinergic-modulated analgesia, but
            corticosterone is linked both to memory for trauma and   later in the cascade, catecholamines produce hyperalgesia
            analgesia. Unfortunately, Pinto-Ribeiro overlooked Uki   in the fight/flight reaction, according to many. 9,66,70,73,74
            et   al.’s results  in which plasma corticosterone levels   There is agreement with Janig’s hypothesis that freeze/tonic
                        72
            indicating traumatic stress are 120 mg in rats.    immobility responses to trauma involve opioid-modulated
              Another critical difference is how long analgesia is   analgesia.
            measured. Drugan et al. monitored SIA for more than 2 h.   For example, both Leite-Panissi  et al. and Souza da
                                                                                                74
                               73
            They found that SIA for rats in escapable stress paradigms   Silva and Menescal-de-Oliveira substantiated that SIA
                                                                                         66
            rapidly declined over 2  h until there was no analgesia,   is  a  cholinergic-modulated  analgesia. However,  others

            whereas rats in inescapable stress paradigms experienced   found that long-term analgesia caused by inescapable
            ongoing analgesia for over 24 h, indicating that a state of   stress is opioid-modulated (endorphins bind with mas-
            tonic immobility had also begun, although the authors did   related gene [MrgX ] receptors) in the spinal horn.
                                                                                                            66
                                                                                2
            not assess that. They did note that rats in the inescapable   Furthermore, Drugan  et al. discovered that naltrexone
                                                                                      73
            stress condition had the benefit of endorphins, whereas   (an opiate antagonist) completely eliminated the analgesia
            the escapable stress rats did not. 73-76  By 1999, Drugan 46   in chronically inescapably shocked subjects but had no
            determined that cortisol and GABA levels were significantly   effect on the analgesic response of chronically escapably
            elevated in the escapable stress conditions and were linked   shocked subjects. In other words, in the case of inescapable
            to both amnesia and interrupted SIA.               stress and hypocortisol, after initial SIA in the nucleus
              This research begged the question: In light of the   raphe magnus, from there, projections into the spinal
            results  in animal models,  does  traumatic  amnesia   horn activate tonic immobility, stimulate endorphins, and
            interrupt analgesia and create susceptibility to chronic   thereby prevent the SNS from activating. In the case of
            pain in humans as well? And, is the pain experience   hypercortisol and escapable stress, after initial SIA, beta-
            governed by peritraumatic perception if it is a byproduct   endorphins are inhibited and excessive glutamate triggers
            of traumatic amnesia, neurochemically downstream from   N-methyl-D-aspartic acid (NMDA) receptor activation of
            glucocorticoid (cortisol) effects? In animal models, one   SNS pain while cortisol prevents ACh from calming the
            study to date showed that cortisol differentiated pain   SNS.
                66
            perception  along  the  same  dose-dependent  lines  as  it   From clinical studies of human beings, we know that
            differentiated memory. Cortisol is critically tied to a fight/  hypercortisol also plays an important role in the onset of
            flight perception of trauma like it is tied to freeze/PTSD.   many types of somatization by causing misattribution and
            Souza da Silva and Menescal-de-Oliveira created chronic   misperception of body signals.  Furthermore, patients with
                                            66
                                                                                       71
            trauma-induced pain in guinea pigs using a controllable   pain disorder, fibromyalgia, and chronic back pain show
            stress paradigm. Importantly, even if only exogenously   reduced gray matter density in cingulate-parahippocampal
            administered (no stress/trauma paradigm), high levels of   or fronto-limbic areas. 11,77,78  Hypercortisol has been
            corticosterone caused ongoing pain.                implicated in brain matter loss in the hippocampus and
                                                               surrounding areas.  We cannot assume that if chronic
                                                                              55
            6.3. Trauma-induced analgesia                      SSD patients present with ongoing hypercortisolism that
            In 2009, Janig  came close to mapping how peritraumatic   it was also the cause of SSD, but there is strong evidence
                       47
            perception dictates whether analgesia or pain is experienced   indicating that hypercortisolism is key to both onset and

            Volume 3 Issue 1 (2025)                         8                               doi: 10.36922/jcbp.4254
   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   16   17   18   19