Page 55 - DP-2-3
P. 55

Design+                                                                 Design chatbot using activity theory



            contexts. Conversational UX Design relies heavily on   the interface of the chatbot is in constant development,
            predefined conversation flows, which may not adapt   changing the appearance as the user and use context
            well to dynamic or evolving user goals.  The framework   develop. The interface and the computer artifact, in the
                                            8
            focuses on chatbot design as an isolated system, which   chatbots are mediators of learning because activity theory
            may hinder its integration into larger workflows or   assumes an asymmetric relation between people and things,
            activities. Conversational UX Design often reacts to user   in contrast to traditional symmetric relations offered by
            input without actively shaping user behavior or workflows.   cognitive science or other computer science approaches,
            Its focus on efficiency and engagement might overlook   where computer programs and human behaviors are
            cultural nuances and diverse user needs. Activity theory,    modeled using the same language and methods. From the
                                                         22
            with its  focus on the  interrelation of tools, goals,  and   activity theory perspective, computer applications, i.e., our
            social contexts, offers a more comprehensive approach to   chatbot, act as a mediator of human activity. 30
            designing adaptive and inclusive chatbot systems.    Applying activity theory for chatbot design enables us
              Understanding  human  activity  and  work practices  is   to make important features of human endeavor stand out
            the focus of activity theory. The principles and components   through  the  hierarchical  structure  of  activity  instead  of
            of activity theory have been used as analytical tools for   designing chatbot applications in isolation. It enables us to
            many different subjects. These include human–computer   focus on the context of use. According to activity theory,
            interaction,  information systems,  interface design,    Computer artifacts can only be understood in their context
                                         24
                                                         25
                     23
                                             22
                               26
            communities of practice,  and education.  There are many   of use, as embedded in meaningful activity.
            advantages for using activity theory for designing usable   An activity comprises a variety of disparate elements,
            and UX chatbots. It is our belief that the theory from AT   voices, and viewpoints.  It is not a homogeneous entity. The
                                                                                 30
            offers us an effective way to design chatbots. Principles   multiplicity can only be understood in terms of historical
            from activity theory have important implications for   layers. Activities are constantly evolving and are not static
            effective chatbot design.                          or rigid. It is important to know how it is developed into its
              An activity is a precursor to learning in activity theory.   existing form to understand a phenomenon.  This applies
                                                                                                  31
            To know something, we must understand the context   to all the elements of an activity. To understand the current
            of doing.  Individual actions are always situated in a   relationship  between  subject  and  object  requires  us  to
                   27
            meaningful context and are impossible to understand in   have a condensation of the historical development of that
            isolation without the meaningful context as the unit of   relationship. 23
            analysis.  Various artifacts, such as procedures, signs,   History plays an important role in activity theory.
                  23
            instruments, methods, laws, etc., are always involved in an   It is not simply an event in the past, but also is alive in
            activity through which actions on objects are mediated.   the present, that may shape the future. The structures
            During the development of the activity, artifacts are   and behavior of today’s learning reflect the culture and
            created, manipulated, and translated, and carry the   circumstance-specific historical development.  Historical
                                                                                                    32
            historical aspect of the development and the outcomes of   analysis enables us to examine existing and emerging
            previous actions on objects. 28                    organizational structures, the result of their evolutionary
              All activities are mediated by culturally defined   development,  sometimes  intentional  and  others  not.
            tools in activity theory. Because activity is mediated,   It is therefore important to describe and analyze the
            the implications for road signs learning is crucial. The   development and tensions within the activity system. It is
            mediation redefines the nature of learning. Learning based   the authors’ belief that by exploiting information relating
            on the activity theory is now re-conceptualized as learning   to users, devices, and environments through the notion of
                                        29
            to participate in a cultural practice.  Instead of viewing it   awareness, using activity theory can bring about effective
            as the rational abstraction of mental representation from   chatbot design. Activity theory offers an ideal framework
            one’s own experience, from an activity theory perspective,   for the design of context-aware systems by providing
            instead of designing learning based on teacher-centered or   guidance on what elements of context to consider to
            student-centered approaches, students move through the   support the implementation process during the design of
            activities and progress from being partial participants, who   the chatbot.
            are heavily dependent on the material mediation of tools,   Our approach allows us to interpret the context of user
            to full participants, who are able to more flexibly use the   behavior in the application. This allows the minimization of
            cultural tools of the narrative practice. 29       explicit input and becomes personalized for the individual
              The interface design of the road sign chatbot is also   user. Minimizing explicit input helps improve usability for
            benefited from applying activity theory. This is because   mobile learners. Applying activity theory to the design of


            Volume 2 Issue 3 (2025)                         5                            doi: 10.36922/DP025060009
   50   51   52   53   54   55   56   57   58   59   60