Page 21 - AIH-2-3
P. 21

Artificial Intelligence in Health                                           AI in embryo selection for ART



            (iv)  Generative models for synthetic data: Images of   requirement for open, and peer-reviewed research remain
               synthetic embryos are produced using generative   to be resolved. The application of AI as a quality control
               models, such as diffusion models and generative   tool post-thawing or for continuous monitoring of embryo
               adversarial networks. Combining these artificial   culturing systems optimizes laboratory workflows. This
               images with actual data enhances AI model training   application allows for a synergistic approach, integrating
               and improves classification performance. 93     the strengths of AI algorithms with the expertise of
            (v)  AI-powered  embryo  ranking  systems:  Deep   embryologists and healthcare professionals to improve
               learning is used by platforms such as the Embryo   ART outcomes. AI can streamline laboratory workflows
               Ranking Intelligent Classification Algorithm to rank   by automating time-consuming tasks, such as embryo
               embryos according to their expected genetic state   evaluation, allowing professionals to focus on critical
               and implantation potential. These systems enable   decision-making. 87
               clinicians to select embryos with the highest potential
               for successful implantation and pregnancy. 95   4.3.4. RQ4: What is the impact of AI-driven embryo
            (vi) Automated morphological feature extraction: AI   selection on the psychological health and decision-
               solutions reduce subjectivity and unpredictability   making processes of prospective parents, particularly
               in assessments by automating the measurement of   in light of ethical concerns?
               important morphological parameters from embryo   It is necessary for ethical considerations to maintain public
               images. 96                                      trust and improve both psychological and clinical results
                                                               in ART.  The use of AI technologies in embryo selection
                                                                     101
            4.3.2. RQ2: To what extent does ART improve the    raises ethical concerns regarding deskilling, transparency,
            pregnancy success rate and live birth outcomes     accountability, and fairness. The absence of transparency
            compared to traditional methods?                   in AI models, which are frequently referred to as “black-
            The performance of ART may be improved using AI and   box” systems, creates uncertainty and undermines trust.
                                                                                                            98
            ML approaches. These techniques also hold a promise for   Furthermore, the  potential repercussions of  AI failures
            the advancement of medical technology in the future.    in embryo selection, which could lead to anomalies
                                                          5
            AI-guided ARTs offer enhanced accuracy, uniformity,   or undesired outcomes, underline the significance of
            and automation compared to traditional ARTs.  AI can   responsibility and fairness in the utilization of AI in this
                                                   76
            accurately identify embryos’ inner cell mass, blastocoel,   sensitive field.  To address these issues and preserve
                                                                           71
            trophectoderm, and zona pellucida. Deep learning   the trust of the public, it is essential to prioritize the
            methods are employed to accomplish this capability and   development of AI models that can be interpreted, carry
            reduce the workload of embryologists, thereby improving   out thorough evaluations through randomized controlled
            the  efficiency  of  ARTs.   In  general,  factors  such  as   trials, and establish regulatory oversight for the application
                                97
            maternal age, the underlying cause of infertility, and the   of these algorithms.  If these recommendations are
                                                                                102
            ovarian stimulation protocols significantly influence the   followed, the integration of AI in embryo selection may
            probability of achieving  successful  pregnancies  and  live   enhance psychological and therapeutic results while
            births. 22                                         upholding ethical standards in ART.
            4.3.3. RQ3: How can AI algorithms be seamlessly    4.3.5. RQ5: What are the primary barriers and
            integrated into existing embryo selection protocols   limitations to the clinical application of AI algorithms
            and laboratory workflows to leverage the expertise of   in embryo selection, and how are these technologies
            embryologists and healthcare professionals?        being developed and validated?
            AI algorithms can enhance embryo selection protocols   AI-based ARTs can reduce inconsistencies, increase clinical
            by leveraging data from  time-lapse imaging, proteomic   and client outcomes, and improve sperm testing and oocyte
            profiles, and morphological features to predict live   quality assessment.  Obstacles to applying AI algorithms
                                                                              103
            birth outcomes and embryo viability. 73,79,98  Although   arise due to the lack of transparency in ML models,
            ML systems are used to predict the results of frozen   ethical concerns about selection errors, and the fact that
            ETs in early pregnancy, their accuracy is limited, and   current embryo-selection algorithms lose diagnostic value
            additional predictors are required to improve predictive   when applied externally to many known implantation
            performance.  By utilizing ML models and computer   embryos.  These limitations are exacerbated by the black-
                                                                      104
                       99
            vision, AI can analyze vast amounts of image data to   box nature of AI models, leading to ethical and epistemic
            automate embryo selection processes.  Nevertheless,   issues, such as unclear responsibility for treatment success
                                             100
            issues such as the interpretability of AI models and the   and biases with unintended consequences.  To address
                                                                                                  105
            Volume 2 Issue 3 (2025)                         15                        https://doi.org/10.36922/aih.7170
   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26