Page 223 - IJB-9-1
        P. 223
     International Journal of Bioprinting                         Cellulose-based bio-inks for bone and cartilage TE
            mesenchymal stem cells (hBMSCs), and a mixture of   after 3D printing as the second crosslink . By varying
                                                                                                 [25]
            both, subcutaneously on the backs of nude mice . The   the T-NCF to Ca  ratio, the mechanical characteristics,
                                                                             2+
                                                    [19]
            NFC aids in enhancing the ink’s capacity to print in this   stability, and  fidelity  of  this  double-crosslinked hydrogel
            situation as well. After 60 days, the explanted constructs   scaffold may be modified. For instance, its hardness can
            all had significant levels of cellular activity, and from days   be changed between 1 and 45 kPa. The carboxylic acid
            30 to 60, both hNCs and mixed groups displayed increased   group in T-NFC can not only enhance the nucleation of
            chondrogenesis and  proliferation  of  glycosaminoglycan   hydroxyapatite to promote osteogenesis, but can also
            (GAG)-positive cells. This study demonstrated that   be used as a crosslinking target to adjust the rheological
            NFC-based hydrogel scaffolds may exert their benefits   properties  of the  ink,  and  its functional  diversity  has
            in animal models while retaining cell viability; therefore,   greatly improved its applications in bone TE.
            we anticipate their widespread clinical application in the
            future.                                            2.2. NCC
                                                               2.2.1. Physicochemical properties and
               TEMPO-oxidized NFC (T-NFC) has a significant    preparation of NCC
            nucleation impact on hydroxyapatite due to the carboxylate   NCC is the smallest of nanocellulose products, with
                                                                                                           [26]
            groups acquired following its modification  and has been   a length of 0.05–0.5 µm and a diameter of 3–5 nm .
                                              [20]
            reported in conjunction with Alg for 3D printing in bone   Compared with NFC, which contains amorphous regions,
            TE . Im et al. used bio-ink obtained from Alg, T-NFC,   NCC contains only crystalline regions, which gives it
              [21]
                                                                                 [7]
            and polydopamine nanoparticles (PDANPs) to obtain   a more rigid structure . NCC is renowned for its high
            osteogenic structures via 3D bioprinting . Compared to   mechanical strength (~7,500 MPa), high aspect ratio (~70),
                                             [22]
            pure Alg gels, the recovery rate and compressive strength   amphiphilicity, and high crystallinity . The preparation of
                                                                                            [27]
            of the T-NFC-containing hydrogels were enhanced. More   NCC is more complex than that of NFC. Cellulose powder
            importantly, the expression of osteogenesis-related genes   is first obtained by washing and mechanical grinding of
            (alkaline phosphatase  [ALP], Runx2,  and OPN) was   lignocellulosic biomass, followed by purification via alkali
            enhanced in composite 3D-bioprinted scaffolds loaded   treatment or acid-chlorite treatment to remove impurities,
                                                                                                       [28]
            with MC3T3-E1 osteoblasts containing T-NFC and     and  finally,  by  acid  hydrolysis  to  obtain  NCC .  The
            PDANPs, along with calcium production and deposition   crystalline portions that are acid-resistant are maintained
            (biomineralization)  on  the scaffolds.  Given  its excellent   during acid hydrolysis, whereas the non-crystalline
            printability, mechanical strength, and capacity to trigger   parts are hydrolyzed because they are not acid-resistant.
            osteogenesis, this T-NFC-containing bio-ink has great   NCC preparation methods have a direct effect on both
            potential for use in bone TE. Interestingly, as a viscosity   morphological traits and physical properties. For example,
            modifier for bio-inks, T-NFC not only increases the   the enzymatic hydrolysis of NCC has better mechanical
            viscosity, but also reduces it when the ink viscosity is too high   and heat properties than acid hydrolysis. The sphere-
            to prevent the restriction of cell activity and proliferation.   shaped NCC obtained via combined hydrochloric and
            Bioactive glass (BG) is frequently utilized in osteogenic bio-  sulfuric acid hydrolysis has greater heat resistance than the
            inks because of its excellent biocompatibility and ability to   usual rod-shaped NCC .
                                                                                 [27]
            stimulate osteogenesis by forming a hydroxyapatite layer   NCC has various applications in medicine, including
            on its surface . A BG-modified gelatin-Alg bio-ink for   TE, medication delivery systems, and antibacterial
                       [23]
            3D bioprinting was developed by Ojansivu et al. However,   agents. In bone TE, NCC can be used as an enhancer,
            after bioprinting, the high viscosity of the ink due to the   additive, or biomaterial to enhance  the mechanical and
            inclusion of BG caused a sharp decline in the activity of the   biocompatibility of scaffolds .
                                                                                     [29]
            loaded cells . After adjusting the ink viscosity by adding
                     [24]
            T-NFC, the  hBMSCs in the printed scaffolds exhibited   2.2.2. NCC 3D bioprinting in cartilage and bone repair
            high activity and proliferative capacity without altering   NCC promotes gelation of composite hydrogels through
            the osteogenic capabilities of BG. The fact that T-NFC   intermolecular hydrogen bonding to improve the
                                                                                                           [30]
            interferes with crosslinking by competing with the Alg   mechanical properties of scaffolds for 3D bioprinting .
            ink for cations produced by BG may be the cause of this   Maturavongsadit  et  al. prepared a bio-ink consisting of
            viscosity-modulating action. Monfared  et  al. added Ca    thermogelling chitosan (CS), NCC, β-glycerophosphate
                                                         2+
            as an ionic crosslinking agent to T-NCF, and the strong   (BGP), and hydroxyethyl cellulose (HEC) to develop
            physical interaction with the carboxyl group of T-NCF   an optimal CS-NCC-based bio-ink for 3D bioprinting
            was used as the first crosslink. In the case of water-soluble   (Figure 1A and B) . The ink is a heat-sensitive hydrogel
                                                                              [31]
            vitamin B as a photoinitiator, the poly (ethylene glycol)   with fast gelation caused by the formation of hydrogen
            (PEG)-added ink was photo-crosslinked under blue light   bonds between CS and NCCs at 37°C (Figure 1C).
            V
            Volume 9 Issue 1 (2023)olume 9 Issue 1 (2023)  215                      https://doi.org/10.18063/ijb.v9i1.637
     	
