Page 35 - MSAM-2-4
P. 35

Materials Science in Additive Manufacturing                      MAM for orthopedic bone plates: An overview



            V, Cr, and Ni to mitigate risks associated with allergies or   A notable advancement in orthopedics, highlighted
            inflammation due to degradation by-products [65,66] .  by AM, is the emphasis on bone plate design, with
              Current explorations primarily revolve around three   topology optimization at the forefront. Pioneering
                                                                                     [33]
            metallic categories: iron-based, magnesium-based, and   work by Al-Tamimi  et al.  initiated this exploration,
            zinc-based materials . Magnesium alloys, for instance,   delving into patient-specific bone plates tailored for
                             [67]
            have been proposed as potential substitutes for permanent   distal tibia fractures. Building on this foundation,
            metals. Chaya et al.  noted their beneficial role in fracture   subsequent research sought to alleviate stress shielding, a
                           [68]
                                                                                                       [46]
            healing and bone formation. However, concerns arise from   recurrent challenge in bone fracture interventions . The
            their swift degradation, sometimes resulting in inadequate   complexity of the design process was further accentuated
                                                                          [74]
            support during crucial healing stages. Moreover,   by Wu  et  al. , who integrated a time-dependent TO
            by-products like hydrogen gas from their degradation can   approach to accommodate bone remodeling dynamics.
            potentially hinder bone formation [28,69,70] . Solutions like the   Notwithstanding the promising outcomes of these studies
            ZX11 magnesium alloy have been explored to tackle these   in curbing stress shielding and enhancing graft longevity,
            challenges .                                       they often hinge on intricate algorithms necessitating
                    [71]
                                                               considerable computational prowess. In a significant stride
              Zinc-based materials, with their moderate degradation   toward practical application, Zhang  et  al.  showcased
                                                                                                  [75]
            rate, have emerged as potential alternatives to their   the  practicality  of  SLM  in  producing  bespoke  biological
            magnesium-based counterparts . Their strength lies in   fixation plates, underscoring the potential of SLM in
                                     [67]
            the absence of hydrogen gas in their degradation products   advancing high-performance biological fixation plates.
            and  complete  absorbability.  He  et al.   showcased  an
                                            [65]
            innovative  biodegradable  iron  scaffold  coated  with   Despite the transformative potential of AM and TO in
            zinc that demonstrated promising bone formation and   bone plate design, it is crucial to acknowledge the existing
            controlled degradation.                            challenges. The computationally intensive nature of TO,
                                                                                     [74]
              The exploration is not confined to metals. Non-  as pointed out by Wu et al. , may hinder its broad-scale
                                                                                 [75]
            metallic materials, particularly bioceramics and specific   adoption. Zhang et al.  provided promising insights into
            polymers, have garnered interest due to their superior   the viability of SLM-produced plates, but the long-term
            biocompatibility and biodegradability [15,27] . Mo  et al.    clinical implications remain underexplored. Moreover, the
                                                        [72]
            highlighted the potential of nanohydroxyapatite (n-HAp)   seemingly boundless design freedom granted by AM and
            orthopedic implants, emphasizing their role in drug   TO is often tethered by practicalities, like screw placement
                                                                                              [76]
            delivery and healing enhancement. However, materials like   constraints, as elucidated by Park et al.  Hence, while the
            polyetheretherketone, despite their promise in reducing   horizons of bone plate design have expanded, realizing the
            imaging artifacts, face challenges in ensuring adequate   full potential of these technologies necessitates addressing
                                   [73]
            support during bone healing .                      these limitations.
              To recapitulate, while strides have been made in the   Pivoting to recent innovations, AM has catalyzed
            evolution of materials for orthopedic implants, challenges   the  advent  of  unique  design  structures  targeting  stress
                                                                                           [77]
            persist. The quest continues for materials that can provide   shielding mitigation. Subasi  et al.  pioneered a finite
            robust, biocompatible, and timely degrading solutions for   element (FE)-rooted design of experiments to discern
            bone healing .                                     the mechanical nuances of lattice-augmented bone
                      [52]
                                                               plates. Their manipulation of design variables achieved
            4.2. Crafting ideal bone plates with AM            a substantial stiffness reduction, hinting at better
            AM has spurred a design revolution, enabling the fabrication   osteosynthesis outcomes. Emphasizing biomechanics, Xu
                                                                   [78]
            of intricate structures that traditional manufacturing once   et al.  showcased AM lattice bone plates, reinforcing
            deemed challenging. With the manufacturing constraints   the need for biomechanical synchronization for
            diminished, designers are now empowered to prioritize   optimal healing. Diverging from conventional designs,
                                                                                   [34]
            product functionality and structural robustness. This shift   Vijayavenkataraman et al.  delved into auxetic structures
            in design philosophy has profoundly impacted multiple   in bone plates, highlighting their potential in attenuating
            sectors, such as aerospace, mobile technology, and notably,   stress  shielding.  Finally,  the generative design approach
            biomedical engineering. Specifically, in orthopedics,   of Kanagalingam et  al.  for patient-specific high tibial
                                                                                  [35]
            the potential of AM to craft innovative and optimized   osteotomy plates stands as a testament to the adaptability of
            orthopedic  implants  has  attracted  significant  research   AM in orthopedics. However, amidst these advancements
            attention,  aiming  to  address  prevalent  issues  like  stress   lies a significant lacuna: the absence of comprehensive
            shielding seen with conventional metallic implants.  biomedical testing for cellular compatibility. While these


            Volume 2 Issue 4 (2023)                         7                       https://doi.org/10.36922/msam.2113
   30   31   32   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40